Laravel load more on pagination not working as expected

I am trying to do load more using jquery

  $response=Event::when(isset($request->id),function ($query)use ($request){
            $query->where('id','>',$request->id);
        })->where(function ($query){
            $query->whereDate('event_start_date','>=',Carbon::now());
            $query->orWhereDate('event_end_date','>=',Carbon::now());

        })->orderBy('event_start_date', 'ASC')
            ->paginate(12) ;

I have 10 posts where id=4 ,5,6 post event will come end because of event_start_date is 30th jan

every time when i click load more i was sending last event id so post 4,5,6 is not appearing because i have condition $query->where('id','>',$request->id);

Sample db data

id |event_start_date | event_end_date
1 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00
2 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00
3 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00
4 |2019-01-27 20:00:00|2019-01-30 20:00:00
5 |2019-01-28 20:00:00|2019-01-31 20:00:00
6 |2019-01-29 20:00:00|2019-01-31 20:00:00
7 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00
8 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00
9 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00
10 |2019-01-15 20:00:00|2019-01-15 20:00:00

can any one help me how i can fix this issue ?

via Chebli Mohamed